Medicare Providers

Find a Medicare Plan

Type of plan



Your zip code
Supplement Plans

Indiana Medicare Supplement Plans

Indiana offers many options for seniors who need additional Medicare coverage. The majority of those eligible often suffer from numerous health issues and this necessitates additional insurance outside of what the government provides. Because of the significant amount of out-of-pocket payments required by traditional Medicare, a booming market of private-sector insurance products has grown up around the government programs. These Medicare-related insurance products are one of the fastest-growing segments of the U.S. health insurance industry overall. And they are the part of the market on which a smart consumer should focus his or her attention.

In Indiana, the most-recognizable names in this market include: Aetna Health, AARP/United Health Care, Anthem/Blue Cross, Coventry Health and Humana Insurance. But these giants aren’t alone—there are dozens of smaller insurance companies selling Medicare Supplement and Medicare Part C/Advantage plans here.

Here is a list of Medicare supplement plans available in the state of Indiana. This data was accurate at the time of publishing, but may no longer be current. Please contact an advisor for more information.

AARP - (United Health Care) Members Only (50+)
(800) 523-5800 A, B, C, F, K, L, N
Ability Insurance Company
(800) 228-6080 A, C, F, G
Admiral Life Insurance
(877) 344-9784 A, B, C, D, F, G
American Family Mutual
(800) 374-0008 A, C, F ,K, L
American Pioneer Life Insurance
(800) 538-1053 A, B, C, D, F
American Republic Corp. Insurance
(866) 755-3065 A, F, F +, K, L
Anthem Insurance Company Inc.
(888) 641-5224 A, F, F+, G, N
Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Company
(866) 458-7500 A, F, F+, G, K
Central Reserve Life Insurance
(800) 734-3942 A, C, D, F, F+, G
Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company
(800) 800-2254 A, B, F, F+, G, K, L, M, N
Combined Insurance Company of America
(800) 544-5531 A, F, N
Conseco Insurance Company
(800) 888-4918 A, D, F, G
Constitution Life Insurance Company
(800) 789-6364 A, B, C, D, F, G
Continental General Insurance Company
(866) 459-4272 A, F, G, N
Continental Life Insurance Company
(800) 264-4000 A, B, C, D, F, G
Equitable Life and Casualty
(888) 352-5120 A, F, N
Everence Association, Inc.
(800) 348-7468 A, C, F, L, N
GE Life & Annuity Assurance
(800) 253-0856 A, C, D, F,
Genworth Life Insurance
(888) 436-9678 A, B, C, D, F, F+, G,
Gerber Life Insurance Company
(800) 704-2180 A, F, G
Globe Life and Accident Insurance Company
(800) 801-6831 A, B, C, F
Great American Life Insurance Company
(800) 880-2745 A, D, F, G
Guarantee Trust Life Insurance
(800) 338-7452 A, B, C, D, F, F+, G
Humana Insurance Company
(800) 872-7294 A, B, C, F, F+, K, L
KSKJ LIFE, American Slovenian Catholic Ins.
(800) 321-0102 A, B, C, D, F, G, M, N
Life Investors Insurance of America
(800) 752-9797 A, B, C, D, F, G
Loyal American Life Insurance Company
(800) 633-6752 A, B, C, D, F, G, N
Marquette National Life Insurance Company
(800) 934-8203 A, D, F, G
Medico Insurance Company
(800) 228-6080 A, D, F
Mennonite Mutual Aid Association
(800) 348-7468 A, C, F, L, N
National States Insurance Company
(800) 868-6788 A, B, C, D, F
North American Insurance
(877) 667-9368 A, C, D, F, G
Pekin Life Insurance Company
(800) 322-0160 A, F
Pennsylvania Life Insurance Company
(800) 275-7366 A, B, C, D, F, G
Peoples Benefit Life
(800) 356-6271 A, B, F, G
Physicians Mutual Insurance Company
(800) 228-9100 A, F, F+, G
Reserve National Insurance Company
(800) 654-9106 A, C, F, F+, N
Royal Neighbors of America
(866) 845-6665 A, F, G
Standard Life & Accident Insurance Company
(888) 350-1488 A, B, C, D, F, F+, G , N
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company
(866) 855-1212 A, C, F
State Mutual Insurance Company
(855) 764-4000 A, B, C, D, F, F+, G, M, N
Sterling Investors Life Insurance Company
(877) 896-6434 A, B, C, D, F, F+, G, M, N
Sterling Life Insurance
(888) 858-8548 A, B, C, F, K
Thrivent Financial for Lutherans
(800) 847-4836 A, B, C, D, F, F+, G, L, M
Unicare Life & Health Insurance
(800) 459-1732 A, B, C, F, F+
United American Insurance Company
(800) 331-2512 A, B, C, D, F, F+, G, K, L, N
United Commercial Travelers of America
(800) 848-0123 A, B, C, D, F
United of Omaha Insurance Company
(800) 354-3289 A, F, G, M
USAA Life Insurance
(800) 845-8026 A, D, F, G
World Corp. Insurance
(800) 822-9993 A, F, F+ , L